Episode 05: Cherrie Mahan

In 1985, a bright, spunky 8-year-old girl got off the bus in Butler County, Pennsylvania. She chatted with her friends until they all went their separate ways. Cherrie Mahan only had to walk around the corner and go up her 150-foot driveway to make it home where her parents were waiting for her. But Cherrie didn’t make it home that day, and 35 years later, Cherrie’s family and friends are still waiting for answers.

To see all of our sources for this episode, along with photos and videos, please visit our blog.