Episode 505: Pepita Redhair
On March 24, 2020, Anita King and her daughter, Pepita Redhair had lunch together before Anita dropped her off at the home she was sharing with her boyfriend, Nicholas Kaye. It was a completely normal afternoon, but it would prove to be the last time Anita would see Pepita. Pepita’s boyfriend claims that she walked out of their Albuquerque, New Mexico home on her own volition to be with another man, but could there be more to the story?
Episode 504: Phoenix Coldon
After Phoenix Coldon turned 18, she entered college at the University of Missouri and moved out of her parents’ house. Her junior year found her back in her family’s deeply religious household, however, and Phoenix began to flounder. On December 18, 2011, she left home and got into the Chevy Blazer that she was sharing with her parents. She made a phone call, drove off, and never returned.
After over a decade of Phoenix’s family trying to get law enforcement and media to pay attention to her case, all that has been uncovered is the fact that Phoenix was living a life that very few people knew about.
Episode 503: Re-Release - Jennifer Kesse
This week marks 18 years since Jennifer Kesse disappeared in Orlando, Florida. This week, we're re-releasing our 2022 episode on her case in hopes of helping her name stay out there. Jennifer's parents, Joyce and Drew Kesse also released a statement about their daughter and the current status of their investigation, which we are reading in full before the episode.
Episode 502: Trevaline Evans
On June 16, 1990, 52-year-old Trevaline Evans put a sign on the door of her antique shop saying, “be back in 2 minutes.” The Llangollen, Wales resident popped over to a nearby store and bought an apple and a banana, then disappeared.
For over thirty years, police have been trying to figure out if Trevaline’s disappearance was related to what was actually happening in her personal life, or if it was because of a killer who happened to be nearby. Strange messages that have popped up in recent years indicate that there is a great deal in the Trevaline Evans case that lies just below the surface.
Episode 501: Leah Roberts
On March 9, 2000, Leah set off from her home in Raleigh, North Carolina, and headed west, following in the footsteps of her literary hero, Jack Keroac. The idea of a spontaneous trip fit in with Leah’s adventurous spirit, so no one was initially concerned, despite the fact that she hadn’t mentioned the trip to anyone.
But as days passed without word, Leah’s family reported her missing. Five days later, her sister Kara got a shocking message: Leah’s Jeep Cherokee had been found wrecked at the bottom of a ravine in Whatcom County, Washington. All of Leah’s belongings were found at the accident scene, but Leah was nowhere to be found.
Bonus - Re-Release: Daniel Bell
When Danielle went missing on September 28, 2001, no one outside of family and close friends looked for her. Everyone gave up on her– but not Danielle’s sister. Now, over 20 years after her disappearance, Bonnie Bell continues to fight for her little sister and for change.
In this episode, Bonnie agreed to speak with us about her sister, the suspects, and her theories on this case, which has yet to be solved.
Episode 427: Tyler Davis
On February 24, 2019, Tyler Davis walked away from the hotel where he was staying with his wife Brittany, and was never seen again. Was Tyler the victim of an accident, or was it foul play? Nearly five years after he was last seen, there is still no trace of the young father. What happened to Tyler Davis?
Episode 419: Erin Marie Gilbert
On July 1, 1995, Erin Marie Gilbert attended the Girdwood Forest Fair in Girdwood, Alaska. She was on a first date with a man named David Combs. David later claimed that he had car trouble and that while he was looking for help, Erin disappeared.
Combs initially cooperated with the police investigation into Erin’s disappearance but quickly stopped talking. As more of his story came out, the less it seemed to add up. So is the simplest answer the correct one? Or, is there a possibility that David Combs, who has never been named as a suspect in Erin’s disappearance truly had nothing to do with it?
Episode 415: Akia Eggleston Update: The Trial
This week, we're bringing you the trial of Michael Robertson, accused of murdering Baltimore mother Akia Eggleston, and their unborn son, Anubis. Akia was reported missing in 2017, but her body has never been found.
Found: Alicia Navarro
Alicia Navarro has been found! Alicia was 14 when she left her parents a note saying, "I ran away. I will be back. I swear. I'm sorry," and disappeared. After nearly four years, the now 18-year-old Alicia walked into a police station in a small town in Montana, over 1,200 miles from her Glendale, Arizona home.
Episode 410: Prisma Peralta Reyes
Prisma Peralta Reyes disappeared from her ex-boyfriend’s apartment building on April 17, 2019. Mesquite, Texas police have marked her case as inactive, but Prisma’s advocates believe there are still answers out there to be found.
EPISODE 408: DANIELLE BELL
When Danielle went missing on September 28, 2001, no one outside of family and close friends looked for her. Everyone gave up on her– but not Danielle’s sister. Now, over 20 years after her disappearance, Bonnie Bell continues to fight for her little sister and for change.
In this episode, Bonnie agreed to speak with us about her sister, the suspects, and her theories on this case, which has yet to be solved.
Episode 405: Steve Cozzi
Host Kona Gallagher discusses the mysterious disappearance of Steven Cozzi, a lawyer who went missing from his office in Largo, Florida under "suspicious circumstances." As a friend of Steve's from high school, Kona shares her personal connection to the case and hopes to bring him home by publicizing his story. Unfortunately, the episode takes a shocking turn as news breaks of an arrest for first-degree murder in relation to Steve's disappearance. Listen now to learn more about the ongoing investigation and how you can help.
Bonus: 9 Missing Person Case Updates
In this episode of "And Then They Were Gone," we provide updates on 9 unsolved missing persons cases that we've covered on the podcast. From Heather Teague to Irene Gakwa, we share any new developments or leads we've uncovered since we last spoke about them. Join us as we continue to shed light on these important cases and bring closure to families and loved ones.
